Is it okay to serve cupcakes at a wedding instead of wedding cake?

Dec 28 2011

Is it okay to serve cupcakes at a wedding instead of wedding cake?

I have a friend who wants to serve cupcakes at her wedding. But I think layered cake would be better.

source: http://answers.yahoo.com/question/?qid=20071207224443AAlcl5H

Wedding cake VS cupcakes. Which do you prefer?
Wedding Cake or Cupcakes?
Wedding Cupcakes in San Diego?
Which would be cheaper & easier for my wedding? Cupcakes or sheet cake?
wedding cake and cupcakes?
What are your thoughts on cupcakes for the wedding cake?
Wedding cake vs cupcakes vs cupcakes with top cake tier?

32 responses so far

  1. I agree with you.

    It’s her wedding day, not her 5 year old’s birthday party.

    Wedding cake is a tradition and it is much more formal than passing out cupcakes!

  2. It’s her wedding, so whatever makes her happy is what you should do.

  3. i’ve seen some really pretty ‘cupcake towers’. i like the idea.

  4. hell no! people r only going there for the food u cant rip them off like that

  5. that would be different and everyone would probably think its childish or something or not going with tradition, but do it if you want ;watever

  6. FUCK NO.
    not to be rude…
    but uhm NONO

  7. It’s her wedding – let her do what she wants. It’s not your fault if it doesn’t turn out the way she wants it to. I went to a wedding with cupcakes and it was actually very well done…they were done in the same sort of presentation as a layered cake and there were different flavors..including carrot cake! yum! If she really wants it done that way – it can be done elegantly. Also – I would say she should be under 40. Older than that – may give the appearance that she just cheaped out. Have fun planning! :-)

  8. The layered cake is definitely traditional…
    If she wants to do cupcakes… then do them… it’s her wedding.
    I have seen these cupcake cakes. They can be so elaborate. It is basically a bunch of cupcakes placed side-by-side to form an object or such, then the frosting is what ultimately connects them to make the picture complete…
    Look into it, that might be a good way to go…

  9. I had Ice Cream at my wedding, and if you like cup cakes get cup cakes just make them look nice and pretty.

  10. i dont think so hun, a wedding cake would definetly be better! i wonder how much they cost tho.

  11. I don’t see a problem with it. I just seen on tv for around 500 bucks you can get a “Krispy Kreme” wedding cake made fron doughnuts. Mmmm, doughnut.

  12. You could have no cake and it would be ok. What ever you want is fine. There will always people who will say something no matter what you do. Do what you want to do and just let it be.

  13. I think cupcakes would be cute. After all they really are just small cakes and people generally get a serving that size anyway. It’s all about what makes the couple happy and what they like.

  14. sundsqk321@sbcglobal.net

    It’s her wedding, so cupcakes it is!

  15. Well, I saw a wedding that had them, just make sure they are more than just white icing on a little cake. Intricate detail would make them appear to be more artsy and stuff rather than cheap and easy.

    Whatever makes her happy.

  16. Is this your wedding? No… It’s her decision.

    And I think it’s great! It’s easier, cleaner, and why not?

  17. wedding cake!!!!!!

  18. ஐ♥Julian'sMommy♥ஐ

    There are plenty of people that are now serving cupcakes and small wedding cakes now at weddings.

  19. it is fine and easier to manage

  20. amandalovesjohn07

    I think if she wants to serve cupcakes, then that’s her choice, maybe cupcakes is just more who she is than a big fancy cake. It’s her day, it should be exactly how she wants it.

  21. Yum Yum. heck yeah its okay. I am doing 19 inch cakes as my center pieces so I can save money on a cake and centerpieces.

  22. Yeah it’s fine. Trust me I felt the same way you do now but I saw a couple layouts and I’m all for them now.Here are a few links to individual cupcakes and some layouts (Right click>>Open in New Window).

    http://www.cupcakefun.com/images/ideas/asinglerosecupcakes/asinglerosecupcakes_zoom.jpg

    http://www.cupcakefun.com/images/ideas/petiteshowercakesccks/petiteshowercakesccks_zoom.jpg

    http://www.weddingcupcakes.org/images/martha_stewart_cupcake.jpg

    http://www.weddingcupcakes.org/images/sibbys_cupcakery.jpg

    http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2206/1809246439_0bafe10508.jpg?v=0

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/cupcake_princess/1143728228/in/pool-67966431@N00/

    http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1186/1249793366_8cab523127.jpg?v=0

    For More pictures check out http://www.flickr.com/groups/67966431@N00/pool/

    Hope this helps.

  23. I think cupcakes are cool. You can get these beautiful towers to display them, you can decorate them all sorts of different ways, and the best thing is there can be a variety of flavours.

  24. IMO, a wedding is an expression of the couple’s tastes, etc, and I don’t think a wedding cake is necessary at all. We’re having a 2 tiered wedding cake for the cutting, then cupcakes for our guests. I love the idea of cupcakes for a few reasons. Wedding cakes usually don’t taste very good, you’re limited in the flavors you can have, they’re too formal for what we’re planning, and we like the idea that cupcakes are a little offbeat, but people still get cake.

    With cupcakes, you can serve loads of different flavors to satisfy all of your guests-we’ll have chocolate, orange, carrot, yellow, spice, strawberry…plus, it’s much cleaner-each person gets their very own serving, and we’ll have lots of kids there–kids love cupcakes, and we’re having a very informal clambake at a local picnic grove, so it just really fits in with the overall vibe of the day. Thankfully, not every bride feels the need to have church/banquet hall/huge white cake!

    Good for your friend!

  25. It’s okay to serve what ever makes her happy…afterall it’s her wedding.

  26. the cupcake tower is a trendy thing and when done nicely can be very attractive

    http://design-wedding-cakes-pictures.blogspot.com/2006/10/elegant-unique-wedding-cupcake-pictures.html

    its not your wedding, how would you have felt if someone tried to tell you your dresses or flowers weren’t good choices.

  27. i think cupcakes are pretty cute. there might be some people there with food allergies and can’t eat a regular cake. good luck.

  28. I don’t really like the cupcake thing for a wedding, but to each his own. If they want to do that then they can. I would have a nice decoration on top of each. Maybe their monogram, or have the icing piped on so the whole top of the cupcake looks like a rose. If they are doing it because they think they are going to be saving money they are mistaken. Making hundreds of cupcakes is just as much work, maybe even more, because they become mini cakes – as making a layered cake.

  29. It is her wedding and she should be able to do it however she wants. It doesnt matter how everyone thinks it ‘should’ be done. It is HER wedding. And for those people who come for the food, they should stay home if they are going to judge someone for what they served at their wedding.

  30. Hi

    What about the best of both worlds? Cup cakes are really popular at the moment but why not combine both cup cakes and a more traditional shape? Cup cakes can work out to be more expensive depending on how they are decorated because they have to be individually decorated.

    See a picture of a wedding cake with both cup cakes and a layered cake here: http://www.my-wedding-cake-ideas.com/wedding-cake.html

  31. Cupcake towers are actually EXTREMELY popular right now, as are tiered cheesecakes, etc. A lot fo brides don;t like cake and want soomething that’s still attractive to serve their guests.

  32. I think it’s a really great idea I’ve seen it done before and it was very elegant.

Leave a Reply